Rich Guy or Caring Guy: Who do I choose?

I’ve been casually dating two guys. First guy is a new lawyer and the other guy is a valet supervisor. I really picture myself with a successful guy. The lawyer guy is cute and smart. But the valet guy is more caring and better in bed. The valet guy wants to be official but I’m hesitant to let go of the lawyer because he’s more successful. I do feel superficial for feeling this way, should I continue just to keep on dating both?

Lin, 30